What's up, it's Zayd.

Think you're actually selling to your prospects? You’re not.

Your sales team gets just 5-6% of your buyer's total purchase journey. The other 94% is made up of all the reasearch, comparing, and decision making that’s done without you.

Something powerful happens in that silent majority of the process, though. 92% of buyers are seeking recommendations from people they trust, and 82% of B2B decision-makers won't even start their journey without a referral.

TLDR: your fancy demos and meticulously crafted pitches matter far less than what others say about you when you're not in the room.

Despite this reality, most companies are still slapping generic case studies on their website and calling it a day. This week, I'm breaking down how to engineer social proof across every stage of your sales process for maximum impact.

Forwarded this email? Get Enabled in your inbox each week.

Zayd’s Picks

My favorite finds of the week.

• The winning proof-point formula (link)

• Everything you need to write good emails (link)

• Top 10 buying signals to track from your website (link)

• Get a new SaaS site to DA30 for free (link)

• Go from zero to one as a vibe marketer (link)

Why Traditional Social Proof Fails

Most companies think about social proof all wrong. They create generic case studies, gather a few testimonials, and add logos to their homepage then wonder why it's not moving the needle.

Here's what they're missing:

The Personalization Gap

Generic case studies rarely address the specific concerns of your prospect. A CTO looking at your security features cares about entirely different outcomes than a CMO worried about campaign performance.

The Timing Problem

Social proof is typically delivered at the wrong time—either too early (logos on a website) or too late (case studies after the demo). The key is delivering the right evidence at moments of decision friction.

The Credibility Crisis

As buyers get more sophisticated, traditional social proof feels increasingly manufactured. Today's buyers can smell a marketing-produced case study from a mile away.

The Social Proof Engineering Framework

After working with hundreds of companies on their outbound strategy, I've developed a systematic approach to building and deploying social proof throughout the sales process:

1. Map Decision Points to Proof Types

Different stages of the buyer journey require different types of social proof:

Awareness Stage:

• Industry-specific metrics

• Relevant customer logos

• Third-party validation (analyst reports, awards)

Consideration Stage:

• Role-specific testimonials

• Challenge-specific case studies

• Feature validation from similar users

Decision Stage:

• Implementation timelines from similar companies

• ROI calculations from comparable customers

• Direct customer references in similar roles

One Valley customer saw their demo-to-close rate jump from. 22% to 37% simply by reorganizing their existing social proof to match these decision points.

2. Build a Social Proof Matrix

Create a database categorizing all available proof points by:

• Industry/vertical

• Company size

• Buyer role

• Primary challenge solved

• Specific feature utilized

• Measurable outcome

• Time to value

This allows your team to quickly pull the exact right proof point for any sales conversation.

3. Implement Trigger-Based Delivery

Don't wait for prospects to ask for proof. Anticipate objections and proactively address them:

Website Triggers: When someone views your pricing page, trigger a pop-up featuring a similar company's ROI calculation.

Email Triggers: When a prospect mentions security concerns, automatically include a relevant security certification or compliance testimonial in your response.

Call Triggers: When discussing implementation timelines, have case studies of similar-sized deployments ready to share on screen.

Follow-up Triggers: After discussing a specific feature, send a short video testimonial from a customer using that exact feature.

4. Leverage Micro-Moments of Social Proof

Beyond formal case studies, build a library of small, high-impact proof points:

• One-line quotes addressing specific objections

• Screenshots of customer Slack messages praising features

• Brief video clips answering common questions

• Before/after metrics relevant to specific challenges

These are perfect for sprinkling throughout emails, chat conversations, and presentations.

5. Create Proof Ecosystems

Instead of isolated testimonials, build interconnected webs of social proof:

• Customer communities where prospects can interact with users

• Industry-specific Slack channels facilitated by your team

• Peer roundtables addressing common challenges

• User-generated content programs that create authentic validation

This approach creates social proof that feels organic rather than manufactured.

How to Get Started

You don't need to overhaul your entire approach overnight. Here's a simple way to begin:

1. Audit your current social proof assets and categorize them

2. Identify your top three sales objections or friction points

3. Create 2-3 targeted proof points specifically addressing these challenges

4. Set up simple triggers to deliver these at the right moments

5. Track the impact on conversion rates at each sales stage

Even this basic implementation can yield significant results within weeks.

The future of social proof means having the right proof points, delivered at exactly the right moment, to the right person, addressing their specific concerns.

How I Can Help?

Let me book sales calls for you while you’re finding social proof. Seriously.

I built Valley to be your automated SDR and empower AEs. Get started today and watch your calendar fill up with qualified leads.