What's up, it's Zayd

I just watched someone steal my Twitter follower and convert them into a paying customer in less than 24 hours.

It was so impressive that I couldn’t even be (that) mad.

Essentially, some guy named John followed a popular creator who helps with company tax compliance and work visas on Tuesday, and then by Wednesday afternoon, he got a DM from this creator's competitor.

"Hey, saw you're looking for help with company taxes and work visas. We can get it done in a week."

John said sure. Became a customer.

The competitor understood that people who follow that specific creator are actively looking to solve that exact problem. So they set up a system to track new followers and reach out immediately.

It’s so obvious, it’s brilliant.

So many founders are sitting on a goldmine of these signals and doing absolutely nothing with them. Excuse the analogy, but it gives the same energy as when you’re playing beer pong and you swipe the ball off the table for a chance at double the points…there was money/a client/an opportunity left on the table, your competitor snagged them, and they ultimately closed the deal that you didn’t.

Zayd’s Picks

My favorite finds of the week

  • Why your cold emails are landing in spam (link)

  • Your cold emails should make people feel good (link)

  • Don’t sell through users to get buyers (link)

  • Habits that lead to PMF with founder-led sales (link)

  • The traditional outbound playbook is dead (link)

The Signals You're Completely Ignoring

342 people viewed your LinkedIn profile last week.

Great!

How many of them did you reach out to?

Because you looked at that notification, thought "cool," and went back to whatever you were doing.

Meanwhile, some of those 342 people are your ideal customers actively researching solutions like yours. They found you. They were interested enough to click. They spent time looking at your profile. The ball was in your court and you ignored them and went back to cold emailing strangers who've never heard of you.

It's like having someone walk into your store, browse for 10 minutes, and then you just stand there watching them leave without saying a word.

The Planet Theory

Think of your company as a planet with gravitational force.

On your planet = People who filled out forms on your website, booked demos, became customers

In your atmosphere = People who haven't converted yet but are clearly orbiting you

They're the definition of warm leads. They already know you exist. They've shown interest.

That's your orbit. It’s your job to do something systematic with it.

The Specific Signals That Matter

Here's what you should be tracking:

  1. LinkedIn-specific signals:

    1. Profile viewers (who looked at your profile)

    2. Post engagers (who liked, commented, shared your content)

    3. Company page followers

    4. Time spent on your profile (Sales Nav shows this)

    5. Content downloads or link clicks

  2. Website signals:

    1. Visitors who didn't convert

    2. Time on site and pages viewed

    3. Return visitors

    4. Specific page visits (pricing, case studies, etc.)

  3. Competitor signals:

    1. People engaging with your competitors' posts

    2. Followers of competitor accounts

    3. Comments on competitor content

  4. Event signals:

    1. People who attended the same conference

    2. Webinar attendees who didn't convert

    3. Event networking tab connections

Right now, you're probably tracking some of this stuff. Maybe you get a notification when someone views your profile. Maybe you can see who liked your post, but what are you actually doing with that information?

The Gap Between Signal and Action

Here’s what typically happens (I know because it happened to me…):

You post something on LinkedIn. It does pretty well. 147 likes, 23 comments, decent reach.

You feel good about it. Maybe you reply to a few comments. Then you move on.

Meanwhile, 47 of those people who engaged are decision-makers at companies that fit your ICP perfectly. They're actively researching solutions in your category. Some of them are probably talking to your competitors right now, but you have no idea who they are because you never looked (or you looked, saw it was a lot of people, and thought "I'll reach out later"). There. Is. Never. A. Later.

By the time you "get around to it," they've already signed with someone else.

The Play-by-Play I Watched Happen

Back to that Twitter story.

The creator John followed has about 50K followers. Posts daily about tax compliance, work visas, international business setup.

The competitor clearly has a system:

  1. Monitor new followers of this creator

  2. Check if they fit ICP (business owners, founders, etc.)

  3. Send a DM within 24-48 hours

  4. Reference the specific problem they're trying to solve

  5. Offer a quick win

John followed on Tuesday because he's dealing with work visa stuff for his startup.

Wednesday afternoon: DM arrives. "Hey, saw you're interested in work visas. We specialize in tech startup visas and can get you set up in under a week. Want to hop on a quick call?"

Context-aware. Timely. Relevant.

John booked the call because it felt like the person actually understood what he was looking for.

💡 LinkedIn Hack of the Week:

Connection requests without a note have a 5% higher acceptance rate than requests with generic notes. Only add notes when you have something genuinely personalized.

Why This Works (& Why You're Not Doing It)

The reason that competitor's system works is simple: timing + context = conversion.

John was actively thinking about the problem (timing). The message referenced his specific situation (context).

Compare that to the cold email John probably got a week later:

"Hi John, I noticed your company is growing fast. Many fast-growing companies struggle with international hiring. We'd love to show you how we can help. Are you available for a 15-minute call?"

Generic. Irrelevant. Ignored.

The reality is that most of us put off doing it because it's manual and time-consuming.

Checking who engaged with your post, researching each person, writing personalized messages, and actually sending them is hours of work for a single post.

The Operational Reality

Okay…so, systematize it.

Every day at Valley, here's what happens automatically:

Step 1: Signal Capture

  • Fetch profile viewers from the last 24 hours

  • Scrape everyone who engaged with our posts

  • Pull new company page followers

  • Collect website visitors who match certain behavior patterns

Step 2: ICP Qualification

  • Score each person against our ideal customer profile

  • Filter out competitors, students, job seekers

  • Flag high-value prospects (title, company size, industry fit)

Step 3: Deep Research

  • For high-fit prospects, research across 60+ data points

  • Pull recent posts, company news, role changes

  • Identify pain points and priorities

  • Find relevant context for personalization

Step 4: Message Generation

  • Craft personalized message in our voice

  • Reference specific context (why we're reaching out now)

  • Include relevant value prop for their situation

  • Keep it conversational, not salesy

Step 5: Outreach

  • Send on LinkedIn (better response rates than email)

  • Track replies and engagement

  • Alert team to positive responses

Step 6: Response Management

  • Route interested prospects to sales team

  • Update CRM automatically

  • Continue conversation where automation leaves off

This runs every single day. Without anyone touching it.

The Numbers

Cold LinkedIn outreach:

  • 8-12% acceptance rate on connection requests

  • 2-5% response rate on messages

  • Maybe 1% converts to actual conversation

Warm outbound (signals-based):

  • 50-70% acceptance rate

  • 30-40% response rate

  • 15-20% converts to conversation

The person who viewed your profile yesterday is 10x more likely to respond than someone you found in a random LinkedIn search because they already know who you are.

🎁 Gift from Zayd:

Only Guide to Safe Outreach on LinkedIn

The Gravitational Pull Strategy

Back to the planet metaphor because apparently I can’t get enough of them today.

Your company has gravitational pull. People are already orbiting you.

The strategy is to:

  1. Increase your gravitational field (post more, create more content, be more visible)

  2. Track who enters your orbit (capture all signals automatically)

  3. Pull them closer (personalized outreach to high-fit prospects)

  4. Land them on your planet (convert to customers)

Play 1: Post Engagement Scraping

Next time you post something that does well:

  • Export everyone who engaged (likes, comments, shares)

  • Filter for ICP fit (use LinkedIn Sales Nav filters)

  • Send personalized messages within 48 hours

  • Reference the post they engaged with

"Hey Sarah, saw you liked my post about signal-based outbound. We actually help companies automate exactly that workflow. Would love to share how we're doing it if you're interested."

Play 2: Profile Viewer Outreach

Check your profile viewers weekly:

  • Identify anyone who fits your ICP

  • Research their recent activity (posts, job changes, company news)

  • Send context-aware message

  • Keep it short and relevant

"Hey Mike, noticed you checked out my profile. Saw you recently joined [Company] as VP Sales. We work with a lot of teams in similar situations scaling their outbound. Happy to share what's working if that's useful."

Play 3: Competitor Engagement Mining

Find competitors' viral posts:

  • Export everyone who engaged

  • Filter for high-fit prospects

  • Reach out with relevant alternative

  • Don't trash-talk competitor (be classy)

"Hey Jennifer, saw you were interested in [Competitor's] approach to personalization. We've built something similar but specifically for mid-market teams. Would love to show you if you're still evaluating options."

Play 4: Event Attendee Follow-Up

After conferences or webinars:

  • LinkedIn shows you who attended in the networking tab

  • Message them without needing connection requests

  • Reference the specific session or talk

  • Offer related resource or conversation

"Hey David, saw you attended the GTM session at SaaStr. The stuff about intent data really resonated with what we're seeing. Would love to compare notes if you're interested."

The Infrastructure You Actually Need

You don't need some massive tech stack for this.

At minimum:

  • LinkedIn Sales Navigator ($80/month)

  • Spreadsheet for tracking signals

  • Calendar tool for booking meetings

  • Some discipline to actually do it

Better:

  • Enrichment tool (Freckle, Apollo, etc.)

  • CRM integration

  • Automation for signal capture

  • Message personalization at scale

Best:

  • Fully automated signal-to-outreach workflow

  • ICP scoring built in

  • Research automation

  • Message quality control

The Common Objections (& Why They're Wrong)

"But isn't this just spam?"

No. Spam is messaging random people who've never heard of you.

This is messaging people who literally raised their hand by viewing your profile or engaging with your content.

They showed interest. You're responding to that interest. It’s like when a girl touches her arm when she’s talking to you (or at least that’s what I’ve heard…).

"Won't this feel automated and weird?"

Only if you do it badly.

The key is actual personalization. Reference the specific reason you're reaching out. Make it contextually relevant.

"Saw you liked my post" is lazy.

"Saw you liked my post about reducing SDR headcount. Noticed you're hiring for 3 SDR roles right now. Curious if you're open to a different approach?" is personalized.

"I don't have time to reach out to everyone."

Exactly. That's why you systematize it.

Just reach out to the ones who fit your ICP. Automate the research, personalize the message, keep humans in the loop for quality.

"My product isn't right for LinkedIn outbound."

Unless you're selling B2C consumer products, you're probably wrong.

If businesses buy your product, the decision-makers are on LinkedIn.

The best leads are the ones who find you first.

Your content brings them to you. Your signals tell you they're interested. Your outreach converts that interest into conversation.

All you have to do is pay attention.

How can we work together 🏔️

  1. See more of Valley’s messaging examples, feel free to roast them: https://coolmessagebro.com/

  2. Generate more demos for your company using LinkedIn: https://meetings.hubspot.com/zayd-from-valley/tryvalley

  3. Become a Valley partner and get 20% recurring commission for every user you bring in: https://withvalley.notion.site/valley-affiliate-partner-program

Keep Reading