What's up, it's Zayd.

For an entire year, Valley's offer was "we help you do better outbound." I rewrote the messages around it constantly. New frameworks, tighter openers, sharper closers, a new hook every few weeks. No matter what I changed, reply rates stayed flat and I kept blaming the words.

What took me too long to realize is that the words themselves were fine, but the actual thing I was offering was worth nothing to a stranger. They had no reason to care, and no amount of sentence craft fixes that.

This week I'm laying out the hierarchy I wish someone had drawn for me two years earlier, because almost every founder I talk to is polishing the last 10% of their outreach while the first 90% sits untouched.

Forwarded this email? Get Enabled in your inbox each week.

My favorite finds of the week

"We help you do better outbound" describes a category. 40 other companies could have sent the same line that week, and several of them probably did. Someone reads it, feels nothing in particular, and keeps scrolling.

in my experience, the order that actually holds up is…

Most teams work that list from the bottom. They start with mail merge tokens and a clever opener, then arrive at the offer somewhere around month five, usually after concluding that “outbound is dead.”

Read your first line the way a stranger with 40 unread messages would read it. If the honest internal reaction is "so what," you have a problem. Nobody has any reason to care about a well-worded description of your company. The key is to give them something. An offer gives somebody a reason to spend fifteen minutes on you this week instead of next quarter. I feel like there was something from Hobbes or Locke or one of the other John’s or Thomas’ during my first semester of college about humans being inherently self interested…in this case, it’s not wrong.

Our messaging now is pretty straightforward. Hop on a demo, give us your offer and your ICP, and we generate a real campaign with messages and 50 leads. You keep the leads either way. People take it because they can picture the outcome before the call even starts, which is the whole job of an offer.

The variant I like even more is asking people to roast our messaging. It beats asking them to take a look, and…it’s funny. Humans will clear their calendar to critique something. Judging is fun, especially when you’re given the keys to the castle to do it without consequence. Handing someone license to tell you you're wrong is more fun and interesting than asking them to admire you, and I've stopped pretending otherwise.

The B2B Growth and Sales Creator Handbook

Saying irrelevant things is weird. You wouldn’t walk up to someone at a party and say "I noticed you went to Michigan." Sure, that’s technically personalized, but it’s also decoration and makes it seem like you have no social skills. Nobody has ever bought software because a stranger correctly identified their alma mater.

Relevance means naming the thing that is costing them money right now. Figure out a problem they have that’s keeping them up at night or they might be too embarrassed to say out loud. It requires a little bit of sleuthing, but the answers are out there. It could be a hiring post that tells you they're staffing a problem your product solves, news about a competitor rollout that clearly went badly, or, more obviously a pricing page visit last Tuesday. Personalization proves you looked. Relevance proves you understood, and only one of those gets a reply.

This is also why signals need stacking. One signal tells you somebody moved. Two or three together tell you they moved for a reason you can help with, and in our data a single signal on its own converts at roughly half the rate.

Watch the video: here

Once the offer holds and the timing is right, the mechanics matter, and they’re boring in the best way.

That last point is where most AI outreach falls over. A single prompt produces something that reads like a single prompt, and buyers have gotten really good at spotting it.

Write your current offer on one line, with no adjectives allowed. Show it to three people outside your company and watch their face rather than listening to their words. Faces are honest.

Then rewrite it as a thing you will do for them before they buy anything, not a thing you claim to be. Build one, ship it to a hundred perfect-fit people, and leave the copy alone for two weeks. If replies move, it was never the copy.